Re: ? Comyn partner off Malise

Concerning the Comyn daughter who was partner regarding Malise regarding Strathearn, I got theorized within the 2005 one to she was basically Margaret, defined as partner out of Sir John de Keith (select duplicate out of post lower than) who had been 2ndly e are given in that blog post: this new spouse Emma I suggest are of another nearest and dearest, and never mom of one’s second Earl Malise.

Scots Peerage, sub _Comyn, Earl from Buchan_ , claims to some extent, ‘Malise, Earl from Strathearn, had a spouse Emma, inside 1261-1267, whose surname is actually unfamiliar ‘[SP II:256, cites Cal. from Docs., i. 2383, 2451]. some time just before 1270, in order that his widow (Margaret) would-have-been “available” some time once Emma.

It was naturally a speculation; it can have the benefit of dealing with a well-known relationships anywhere between Muriel Keith and Reginald le Cheyne. Any further related papers create naturally feel anticipate.

The new account in Scots Peerage towards class of Keith says out-of Sir John de- Keith (d. california. 1270) which he are believed to features married Comyn, earl off Buchan . It character, of the undecided (“thought to have been”) diversity, can end up being corrected based on the after the dispensation, dated in the Fondi with the 14 Jan 1378/9::

‘ Reg Aven 215, fifty On bishop out of Moray. Professors so you can dispense Reginald Cheyn, donzel, and you may Murielle, damselle, d de Keth, off Moray and you may Aberdeen dioceses, on obstacle so you can relationships as a result of the third and you will last degrees of consanguinity. Fondi, 19 Kal. Feb., anno 1. SRO Vat. Trans., iv, no. 46. ‘

Muriel Keith, the near future 2nd wife from Robert Stewart, 1st Duke regarding Albany (d. 1420), is actually developed in order to wed Reginald ce Cheyne, child regarding Sir Reginald le Cheyne because of the their wife (while the her first husband), Helen out of Strathearn. If you’re you can find known holes from the origins from Muriel Keith, she and Reginald le Cheyne would share a lineage on the Comyns. Yet not, that is also faraway to require a good dispensation in the event that Muriel was an effective-great-great grandd Comyn, Earl regarding Buchan (d. 1233), which may become case if the ‘s child.

dos. Reginald ce Cheyne is a good-grandson of Marjory Comyn, child away from Alexander Comyn, Earl out of Buchan (d. 1290), young buck of William Comyn in the list above. Their unique son was Malise, Earl regarding Strathearn from 1312 so you’re able to their passing within the 1328 , and you will father out-of Reginald.

california. 1270), is actually same as Marjory Comyn, and you may married 2ndly so you can Malise, Earl of Strathearn (d. 1312). This would mean the newest parentage a€?thought to keeps been’ compared to Margaret, partner out-of Sir John de Keith, try away from one age bracket: she’d n’t have come the newest d Comyn, Earl regarding Buchan, but instead out-of their young man Alexander. There isn’t any facts you to Earl Malise and you can Marjory Comyn was in fact partnered much before 1275: once the Lindsay published,

There clearly was you to discernable base on what the partnership ranging from Reginald le Cheyne and you will Muriel Keith will have lived: if the Margaret Comyn, spouse regarding Sir John de Keith (d

‘ The spouse with the earl, from the 1275, was entitled Marjory, while we understand the attesting term off No. cv., and is mentioned by Wyntoun, Publication VIII. guy. vi., to own become the next brother out online kinesisk datingsida of John Comyn, Earl out-of Buchan, who negotiated with respect to Earl Malise the marriage payment more than mentioned [dated on London area, April 26, 1293 for his daughter Matilda and you may Robert de- Tony, young buck away from Ralph].’

Alexander Comyn = Age de- Quincy E away from Buchan I __________________I________________ I III step one) Sir John = Marjory = 2) Malise de Keith I (als We Elizabeth off Strathearn . 1270 We Margaret) We d. 1312 _____________I__ ___I__________________________ We I We I We I Sir William Bernard Malise Gilbert Robert Maud de- Keith de- Keith Age off = Robert d. bef 1293 Strathearn; d. 1328 de- Tony We ______I_______________________ I We I We Sir Edward Malise Mary Helen = Isabella de- E away from Strathearn = 1) Sir Reginald Synton d. ca. 1343 I ce Cheyne We We I = 2) Sir David I V I I de Graham Sir William de We I__________ Keith I I = Margaret Fraser __________________I_______ V __I_____________ I I I III I We I I Muriel + Reginald Mary Mariota Keith ce Cheyne (= Robert Stewart, Duke regarding Albany)